Home Title Index Topic Index Sources Directory News Releases Sources Calendar

Using diversity to eviscerate diversity

Malik, Kenan
http://kenanmalik.com/2023/01/12/using-diversity-to-eviscerate-diversity/

Date Written:  12/01/2023
Year Published:  2023  
Resource Type:  Article

On a controversy over an image depicting Muhammad.


Abstract: 
-

Excerpt:


What is striking about the Hamline incident, though, is that the image at the heart of the row cannot even in the most elastic of definitions be described as Islamophobic. It is an artistic treasure that exalts Islam and has long been cherished by Muslims.

Yet, to show it is now condemned as Islamophobic because - a student says so. Even to question that claim is to cause 'harm'. As Berkson asked in another (unpublished) letter he sent to The Oracle, after his first had been removed: "Are you saying that disagreement with an argument is a form of 'harm'?"

That is precisely what the university is saying.

One can only wonder that the university bureaucrats who declared representations of Muhammad to be proscribed by Islam did not ask themselves why, if this was true, there were figurative Islamic paintings to show the class in the first place? There has developed a historical amnesia about the many Islamic traditions, especially Persian, Turkish and Indian, which have celebrated portrayals of Muhammad; portrayals found in manuscripts, paintings, postcards, even in mosques.

While there have always been debates on this issue within Islam, the strict prohibition on picturing Muhammad is primarily Sunni and relatively recent. The growth of Wahhabism, a fundamentalist strand of Islam that developed in the 18th century and came eventually to be the ideological cement of modern Saudi Arabia, has been particularly important. Saudi petrodollars have allowed the fanatically austere character of Wahhabism to find greater global purchase.

Topics
Sources-journalists use the sources website to find you


AlterLinks
c/o Sources


© 2023.